| |
Hard
Candy: More Like a Jawbreaker
Ellen Page, Patrick Wilson
Review
by Breanne Boland
April
20,
2006 Issue
Hard Candy isn’t
an easy film. It makes the viewer squirm and writhe and, if they’re
especially demonstrative, gasp. However, its strength is that
it makes you squirm in about five different ways, making you uneasy
over and over as the truth of the story changes.
Hayley and Jeff meet
online and arrange to get together at a nearby restaurant. It
sounds innocuous enough, at least when viewed through the flirtatious
instant message conversation in which we first encounter them.
The reality is somewhat different—when we see them, they
look more like they should be meeting for a student-teacher conference
than for a date. Hayley is 14 years old, and probably the smallest,
most elfin-looking 14-year-old on earth. Jeff is a 32-year-old
fashion photographer whose models are often not much older than
Hayley. He’s aghast when she suggests that he might be anything
less than strictly professional with the often-underage models,
but his righteous defense falls a little flat as he tries to explain
himself to the cute little teenager drinking vodka in his living
room.
It’s sketchy
at best, although Jeff tries, bogglingly, to come across as a
nice guy with purely good intentions. He tries to be self-effacing
and jovial, anything to distance himself from his position as
predator. However, when Hayley drugs his drink and he wakes up
tied to a chair, their roles are neatly reversed, and Hayley has
no such qualms about being in the position of power. Her tormenting
isn’t about physically hurting him so much as making him
acknowledge what he is, the part of him he’s so successfully
compartmentalized.
Over the next hour,
Hayley carries out her version of justice. Her ideas are some
that I’m sure most people have had when they think of adults
who prey on kids, exploiting children for their own one-sided
pleasure. However, seeing her toy with him, keeping him completely
helpless and ignorant as to what she’s going to do next,
makes you question those vivid, horrible thoughts that arise whenever
you hear about a child or a teen disappearances on the news—being
led away from their parents and their lives, to never be seen
again or at least never be the same. It’s impossible to
be fully on Jeff’s side in the matter, especially once he
begins to admit what he is and what he does, but it’s not
easy to root for Hayley and her crusade either.
As Hayley, Ellen Page,
who will soon be seen as Kitty Pryde in the next X-Men movie,
is perfectly believable as both the innocent, giggling child who
acts as pervert bait and as the avenging lioness who makes Jeff
regret every unfortunate impulse he’s ever indulged. Patrick
Wilson, probably most recognizable for his work in Angels in America
and Phantom of the Opera, does a remarkable thing in making his
deviant character both condemnable and sympathetic. Working together
with their two-faced roles, the actors bring to life a difficult
story that gives the viewer no quick conclusions. Both are right
and both are wrong and the film does the great act of giving the
audience fodder for a long deliberation about justice, revenge,
and culpability without suggesting how you should feel when the
credits start.
Bottom line:
Hard, but worth the effort.
More
from Breanne Boland
More movie reviews
(Top)
|
|
|
Dropouts
Step Out: Take the Lead
Antonio Banderas, Alfre Woodard
Review
by Bruce Collier
April 20,
2006 Issue
Liz Friedlander’s
Take the Lead is the latest in a long line of genre movies, one
that began small with Blackboard Jungle, went big time with To Sir,
With Love, and just keeps on going. Big or small screen, the premise
is always the same. No-nonsense, idealistic teacher goes to tough
school, reaches unreachable kids through unconventional methods.
Those methods have included music, sports, chess, and theater. Here
it’s ballroom dancing.
Antonio Banderas
plays Pierre Dulaine (he reconciles the French name and the Spanish
accent early on), a New York ballroom dance instructor with his
own school. Dulaine deftly prepares his clientele of mostly white
upper class kids for cotillions and posh dance competitions. A chance
encounter with street vandalism leads him to the aforementioned
tough school, a mostly black and Hispanic high school in a depressed
neighborhood.
Cutting through
a lot of red tape—this is Zorro, remember—Dulaine persuades
a steely-eyed principal, played by Alfre Woodard, to let him teach
ballroom dancing to a pack of “rejects,” doing eternal
detention in a basement room. In short order, Dulaine has charmed
the kids, converted the dreary basement into a hip-hop Rainbow Room,
and pumped them to the gills with inward and outward respect.
That’s
the message of Take the Lead. Respect is the silver bullet, and
if dancing instills respect, then let’s teach dancing. It
makes sense, at least in the context of the movie. It doesn’t
hurt that Dulaine dresses elegantly, stands and opens doors for
ladies, and moves like Fred Astaire. And, of course, he looks just
like Antonio Banderas.
One could dismiss
Take the Lead as the same old same old. It has many clichÈs—Gershwin/Porter
tunes clashing with rap and urban dance mixes, Old World manners
versus blunt street crudeness. The kids all have issues - body issues,
home life issues, and parental expectation issues. And at the end,
of course, is the Big Dance Contest. But that’s the point.
Genre films
become genre films because people like them so much that Hollywood
keeps turning them out to the point where they become, well, genre
films. Take the Lead can be enjoyed as exemplary of its kind. Banderas
can’t help but charm, whatever he does. The “lost”
kids, notably Rob Brown, Yaya DaCosta, and Lauren Collins, are funny
and personable, though about as genuinely menacing as a pack of
Chihuahuas. And, without a hint of computer-generated imaging, they
are all great little dancers.
Which, of course,
is what we all came to see. Yards of dance footage. Lots of Cinderella
transformation and growing self-awareness. Never mind that the script
is full of cliches and faux-portentous dialogue. In the mouths of
good actors, this stuff comes across.
Skeptical? Read
out loud the screenplay to a favorite movie, say, Gone with the
Wind, some time.
Yeah. Vivian
Leigh didn’t get that Oscar for nothing, did she?
Bottom Line:
That’s all there is, so let’s keep dancing.
More
movie reviews
(Top) |